Siobhan McMahon MSP

I am was very disappointed at the decision to withdraw preferred bidder status from St Philip’s Secure Unit in Plains, Airdrie. Not only will this lead to the closure of the unit, it may also render the other two facilities on the St Philip’s site, the residential school and St Francis Day Unit, financially unsustainable.

St Philip’s was only opened five years ago, at a cost of £15 million, £5 million of which was borne by the taxpayer. It has an excellent record of providing first-class care, and staff have been praised for their commitment and dedication. However, in this instance, and to the detriment of both staff and children, cost has been placed before care.

With the decision unlikely to be altered, the priority moving forward is to ensure the appropriate transitional arrangements are in place to ensure continuity of care for the vulnerable children who are facing considerable upheaval. Additionally, St Philip’s highly trained should not be abandoned.

I was surprised to hear that, despite assurances to the contrary from both local MSP Alex Neil and Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill, Skills Development Scotland were not immediately informed of the situation. I understand that PACE (Partnership Action for Continuing Employment) is now involved, but at the request of St Philip’s management, not the Scottish Government.

It is disappointing that the Scottish Government have failed to back their words with action, and I fully appreciate the frustration and anger felt by staff and children alike. If the Scottish Government is serious about providing the best care and guidance to vulnerable young people, it must realise that this comes at a cost. Cutting corners now will only store up problems for the future.